His ESOP Stock Grew From $80,000 to $400,000. One IRA Rollover Could Turn $320,000 of Appreciation Into Ordinary Income.

Rolling ESOP stock into an IRA permanently eliminates NUA tax treatment, converting $320,000 of potential long-term capital gains into future ordinary income.

Under the NUA rule, only the $80,000 plan basis triggers ordinary income at distribution; the $320,000 appreciation stays deferred until shares are sold.

A split strategy lets employer shares move in kind to a taxable account while other plan assets roll into an IRA, preserving NUA without full exposure.

Read More: Avoid these 13 retirement mistakes before they derail your future (sponsor)

Picture a man in his mid-sixties who spent his career at an employee-owned company. The company contributed shares to his employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) over the years, and now the stock has a current value of roughly $400,000 against an $80,000 plan cost basis.

He is also collecting Social Security and wants to simplify retirement by rolling the entire account into an IRA. That sounds routine. But moving the employer stock into the IRA can permanently surrender special tax treatment on $320,000 of appreciation and change when that money collides with the taxation of his Social Security.

The rule is called net unrealized appreciation (NUA). When qualifying employer securities are distributed in kind from a qualified retirement plan as part of an eligible lump-sum distribution, the appreciation that accumulated inside the plan can remain untaxed at distribution. The plan cost associated with the shares is generally taxed as ordinary income, while the NUA receives long-term capital-gain treatment when the shares are eventually sold.

In this example, the $80,000 basis can create ordinary income when the shares leave the plan for a taxable brokerage account. The $320,000 of NUA remains deferred until he sells the stock, when that portion generally receives long-term capital-gain treatment. An IRA rollover produces a different result. If the employer stock is rolled into an IRA, the special NUA treatment generally disappears. Future taxable IRA withdrawals are treated under the ordinary rules for IRA distributions rather than preserving the stock's old NUA character.