Lammy’s cuts to jury trials could have ‘far-reaching’ effect on race relations, say MPs

Justice secretary’s plans likely to increase black people’s suspicion of court system, committee suggests

David Lammy’s planned changes to the criminal courts in England and Wales could have a “far-reaching” impact on race relations, a cross-party committee of MPs has concluded.

The deputy prime minister’s plan to remove the right to elect for a crown court trial “has the potential to increase mistrust in the criminal justice system among the black community”, the justice select committee said, because black defendants are more likely to elect for trial.

A report released on Wednesday called for the government to set a “clear national target” for the number of black members of the senior judiciary after “shocking” figures showed that just 1% of crown court judges were black.

The government is braced for possible rebellions when the courts and tribunals bill returns to the Commons for its committee and report stages, when amendments are considered and voted on.

Andy Slaughter, the chair of the committee and a Labour MP, said: “The committee shares the significant concerns of many in the justice sector around the potential equality impacts of the bill, particularly in relation to race.

“It is shocking that only 1% of crown court judges are black, a figure that has not changed since 2015. The persistence of such stark underrepresentation demonstrates that efforts to date have failed to deliver meaningful change.

The government must take action and set out a clear national target to achieve a representative judiciary and magistracy by 2035,” he said.