Lord David Alton criticizes Vatican's China agreement as "deal with the devil

Lord David Alton has labeled the Vatican's agreement with China as a “deal with the devil” during an interview with Crux Now. The comments come as the Catholic peer discussed a religious freedom petition that he signed, which was organized by Aid to the Church in Need (ACN). This petition, aimed at raising awareness of religious persecution, coincides with ongoing tensions surrounding the Vatican's relationship with Beijing.

The Vatican's 2018 agreement with China was intended to improve relations and establish a framework for the appointment of bishops in the country. However, critics argue that the deal has compromised the Catholic Church's autonomy and led to increased state control over religious practices. Many believe it has undermined the rights of underground church members and has not effectively addressed ongoing human rights abuses in the region, particularly against Uighur Muslims and other religious minorities.

Alton's remarks reflect deep concerns within the Catholic community about the implications of the Vatican's engagement with the Chinese government. John Pontifex, also of ACN, echoed these sentiments, emphasizing that the Vatican's approach has left many believers feeling abandoned. The petition aims to garner support for victims of persecution and to call for a reassessment of the Vatican's strategy in China.

The future of the Vatican-China agreement remains uncertain as tensions between the two entities persist. As reports of religious repression continue to emerge, the Catholic Church may face increasing pressure to reevaluate its diplomatic stance. The outcome could have lasting implications for religious freedom in China and the global Catholic community's response to state-sponsored persecution.